uuid:b59a5fea-d19b-46a4-88e5-b0dfb9bb3889
xmp.did:702E84AA30EEDF11A82EBDD7556A27D3
adobe:docid:indd:55b2be19-d352-11de-a31b-ffe24ab5dd96
proof:pdf
xmp.iid:6F2E84AA30EEDF11A82EBDD7556A27D3
xmp.did:26E0390ADABFDF11AB1DF20C369C5409
adobe:docid:indd:55b2be19-d352-11de-a31b-ffe24ab5dd96
default
saved
xmp.iid:DF4F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T12:11:40+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:E04F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T12:11:40+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E14F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T12:57:47+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E24F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T12:57:47+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E34F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T13:05:54+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E44F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T13:05:54+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E54F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T13:06:32+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E64F1135F500DF1183D4C400F4FDAB2A
2010-01-14T13:06:32+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:8B8F7935800ADF1196F4F0D3B5D1C75F
2010-01-26T15:39:21+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:EB908C55810ADF119871DD04D56AB754
2010-01-26T15:47:24+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:A7846867300FDF11BF5AA4F055A5AD9D
2010-02-01T14:50:41+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:B057E256CA0FDF119599DE52A871FFD0
2010-02-02T09:12:35+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:3825F28ACA0FDF119EBECC396F3E9DAD
2010-02-02T09:14:03+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:3925F28ACA0FDF119EBECC396F3E9DAD
2010-02-02T09:14:03+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:3A25F28ACA0FDF119EBECC396F3E9DAD
2010-02-02T09:15:25+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:3B25F28ACA0FDF119EBECC396F3E9DAD
2010-02-02T09:15:25+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:750D6B85D60FDF1188BCB36B58452661
2010-02-02T10:39:48+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:31194067DE0FDF11A5B2A403972F4363
2010-02-02T11:36:13+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:07ECB50BEE0FDF11BBB4F6BC3B9209ED
2010-02-02T13:28:11+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AD4FC578CB10DF118A8CA43869F3300B
2010-02-03T16:25:54+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:AE4FC578CB10DF118A8CA43869F3300B
2010-02-03T16:25:54+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:E17C070C2C12DF11B142D80DAF079995
2010-02-05T11:11:41+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:9FE1915B7B14DF11A14BB0E9A56DDE1E
2010-02-08T08:29:51+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:867F6D139614DF11848FA3FFF101FBD9
2010-02-08T11:41:04+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:897F6D139614DF11848FA3FFF101FBD9
2010-02-08T12:15:11+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:32753A1AB714DF118E28FDBAA5305E60
2010-02-08T15:37:29+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:176951A1BB17DF118887886E4ABEDC0E
2010-02-12T13:23+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:CF46D29CBB1BDF11B4B8FDDE6A3F4A4C
2010-02-17T14:00:48+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:A3827179AE38DF1189E6F2A4962AD137
2010-03-26T10:06:25+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:3477E364B243DF1186869D4BEEF890CA
2010-04-09T10:55:53+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AD3170A1C343DF11BE778C82F63CB51F
2010-04-09T12:48:45+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AE3170A1C343DF11BE778C82F63CB51F
2010-04-09T15:13:08+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:6ECB6C039247DF1195BFCCF10E897A16
2010-04-14T08:50:29+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:12FCE54E724CDF1199E8951AD8227FCF
2010-04-20T14:12:15+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AF3853F2DF58DF11A4F6F892A2F259B1
2010-05-06T12:17:44+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:0DFFBACC0359DF11A4F6F892A2F259B1
2010-05-06T13:37:49+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:CF57CA045462DF11B6D2C7DCD6C7E964
2010-05-18T10:04:44+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:D057CA045462DF11B6D2C7DCD6C7E964
2010-05-18T11:13:41+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:FACCD3D48062DF11B59BA25A0A8354F6
2010-05-18T15:25:31+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:FBCCD3D48062DF11B59BA25A0A8354F6
2010-05-18T15:26:18+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:FCCCD3D48062DF11B59BA25A0A8354F6
2010-05-18T15:26:23+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:88D17199AA7ADF11BCBDBB26D015DE34
2010-06-18T09:45:10+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:918620765683DF11BC59B35A780499F7
2010-06-29T13:01:10+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:DDA394163E88DF119F88D8B0E8A3931B
2010-07-05T16:03:29+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:6F485926118FDF11837EA4CEF60DBE4A
2010-07-14T08:32:18+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:A8A10BA7AF90DF11B12C9778406FCB23
2010-07-16T11:10:26+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AC8CD32B9094DF11895AA966BA2EADDB
2010-07-21T08:21:17+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:AF8CD32B9094DF11895AA966BA2EADDB
2010-07-21T08:36:03+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:D0C753EAFEBEDF11BFC0D36D35EC0202
2010-09-13T08:19:50+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:D1C753EAFEBEDF11BFC0D36D35EC0202
2010-09-13T08:19:50+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:566B6F5D37BFDF119FFF87DEABBE45F2
2010-09-13T15:03:55+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:596B6F5D37BFDF119FFF87DEABBE45F2
2010-09-13T16:12:18+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:5A6B6F5D37BFDF119FFF87DEABBE45F2
2010-09-13T16:16:04+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:25E0390ADABFDF11AB1DF20C369C5409
2010-09-14T10:32:04+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:26E0390ADABFDF11AB1DF20C369C5409
2010-09-14T10:32:04+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:27E0390ADABFDF11AB1DF20C369C5409
2010-09-14T10:32:43+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:36F4E256E2C6DF11AAA5A68FD48543AC
2010-09-23T09:15:26+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:BE76034298E1DF1194F6A7BDBDCC45F2
2010-10-27T09:09:23+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:6F2E84AA30EEDF11A82EBDD7556A27D3
2010-11-12T11:22:43+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:702E84AA30EEDF11A82EBDD7556A27D3
2010-11-12T11:22:43+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/;/metadata
saved
xmp.iid:712E84AA30EEDF11A82EBDD7556A27D3
2010-11-12T11:25:01+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
saved
xmp.iid:0720E97B2FF2DF11BC80CC9765118388
2010-11-17T15:08:50+02:00
Adobe InDesign 6.0
/
2010-11-18T09:34:04+02:00
2010-11-18T09:34:04+02:00
2010-11-18T09:34:04+02:00
Adobe InDesign CS4 (6.0.4)
JPEG
256
256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4113
xml
Adobe PDF Library 9.0
False
Concerted intervention needed to escalate PhD numbers: A comment
Author:
Musa C. Mlambo1,2
Affiliation:
1Department of Biology, University of Oulu, Finland
2Freshwater Research Unit, Department of Zoology, University of Cape Town, South Africa
Correspondence to:
Musa Mlambo
email:
musa.mlambo@gmail.com
Postal address:
Freshwater Research Unit, Department of Zoology, University of Cape Town, Private Bag, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa
How to cite this article:
Mlambo MC. Concerted intervention needed to escalate PhD numbers: A comment. S Afr J Sci. 2010;106(11/12), Art. #498, x pages. DOI: 0.4102/sajs.v106i11/12.498
© 2010. The Authors. Licensee: OpenJournals Publishing. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution License.
The Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf), mandated to provide evidence-based advice to the government on scientific matters, has released a report1 exploring the current state of affairs regarding South Africa’s potential to produce doctoral graduates. The authors of the report did a sterling job, performing thorough and elaborate research, amassing lots of facts and finally making ten recommendations. However, I object to the very first recommendation, which states ‘Escalate the numbers of doctoral graduates through external intervention programmes, for which there is successful precedent in recent South African history’. This recommendation advocates that in order to rapidly increase the numbers of doctoral graduates, the government must focus on funding doctoral candidates en masse to study abroad. As policy advice I find this recommendation absurd and unacceptable.
I am working under the assumption that this recommendation is listed first because, in the view of the report’s authors, it should be the top priority. In other words, it is the ‘take home message’ of the report. Perusal of newspaper articles that covered the launch of the report, confirms this assumption, as they have headlines that read ’Send doctoral students abroad - says the report’. I cannot overestimate the damage caused by such a message, as it feeds directly into the stereotype that this report uncovered: a view of PhD studies as ‘just for personal gain’, or for the elite, but not in the collective interest of society. If the recommendation of sending doctoral students abroad were to be adopted, it would make it very difficult then to realise the other recommendations. For example, how would the other recommendation calling for closer cooperation between universities and industries be realised?
The foundational question to this discourse is why does South Africa want to escalate the number of doctoral graduates it produces? If the reason is merely to boast about the numbers of doctoral graduates per million people, then this recommendation could be an expedient way to achieve this aim. By contrast, if the reason is connected to using scientific knowledge for economic, social and ecological development,2,3 then this recommendation would be counter-productive. It is fitting at this point to mention that doctoral students are the lifeblood of research and innovation, providing the country where the research is conducted with a competitive edge. Worth noting is the fact that benefits of research are not gained by the country of origin of the PhDs, but the country where the research is conducted. Therefore, in terms of the link between doctoral graduates and economy,3 the issue is not about how many PhD students South Africa can export to other countries – or how many South African passport holders have doctoral degrees – but how many doctoral graduates South Africa does (or can) produce. South African passport holders undertaking doctoral studies abroad do not necessarily contribute to South Africa’s economy and knowledge development. In addition, the intellectual property of the research that a PhD student conducts resides with the country where the PhD degree is registered. In other words, if South Africa makes a strategic decision to finance most of its PhD students to study abroad, it is inadvertently improving the competitive advantages of those countries. To sum up, sending PhD students abroad would not only remove the economic stimulus which South Africa could potentially enjoy, but also the intellectual property (both in terms of the brightest minds and also the hard-earned product of those four years or so of research).
The report’s reference to South Africa’s recent past – when a selected number of PhD students were recruited by international institutions to earn doctorates abroad – as a motivation for this policy recommendation is unfortunate and warrants a separate comment altogether. The interventions that were done at that time were at a small (or individual) scale and were not strategic policies by the South African government. I doubt the feasibility of extrapolating from such a small scale to national level. But more important, during the apartheid era, educating some of South Africa’s best brains abroad was a strategy to bring about political change. As a democratic country, South Africa’s government now has to devise its own policies to achieve economic development. Investment in training a large pool of PhD students is an expensive, long-term endeavour that South Africa needs to make one of its top priorities, because failure to do so will hinder its competitive ability and ultimately its economic sustainability.
I was glad to learn – though no data were provided – that more than 90% of those who earned their PhD degrees abroad during that period returned to South Africa to contribute their newfound skills to the development of the country. However, things have changed much since those days and I doubt if such commendable fidelity would be seen today. Interestingly, the report found that more than 40% of non-South African PhDs studying in South Africa intends to stay in the country after completion of their studies. This is significant considering that non-South Africans accounted for 45% of the total headcount of PhDs in South Africa institutions.
The report’s lack of reference or coherence with the other strategic national frameworks is regrettable. For example, the National Research Foundation together with the Department of Science and Technology recently launched an initiative entitled the SA PhD project4 with a stated aim to achieve a five-fold increase in the annual production of PhDs from ~1200 to 6000 by 2025. Discussing the recommendation of this report in the context of this initiative would have given it more impetus.
South Africa is richly endowed with unique resources (cultural and ecological5) that urgently need to be researched and understood. In fact, South Africa is busy inviting the world to come study our systems (e.g. the bid to host the Square Kilometre Array6). Therefore it would be unseemly to send our PhD students abroad to study foreign systems. Although many theories and principles that we use to make sense of the world are universal, most were developed from western viewpoints. That is why there is an increasing number of scholars5,7 calling for a better appreciation of African knowledge.
Given the ever-increasing bureaucratic and administrative duties, not to mention teaching loads, academics are left with little time to actively conduct research on their own. That is why they supervise PhD students to do the laboratory work, or fieldwork, and write up the results. As shown by the report, PhD students spend on average 4.6 years to fulfil the requirements of PhD degrees. Taking away these invaluable contributions that PhDs currently make would disadvantage South African academics.
I presume that the recommendation to send PhDs abroad is a temporary measure – although it was not explicitly stated so in the report – because otherwise it would not be sustainable. Nevertheless, before this recommendation can be implemented, we need to first ask ourselves some difficult questions. What is the plan for the period starting from the year we send our first cohort of PhDs until they come back (if they do come back)? Armed with new skills and eager to start research careers but without connections with local industries, where is this cohort going to find students with whom to work? Will it not by then be entrenched in the minds of everyone that in order to get a PhD you must study abroad? And how will this generation that was funded by the government to study abroad be able to convince the next generation to stay in South Africa and work under its supervision?
REFERENCES
1. Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf). The PhD study: An evidence-based study on how to meet the demands for high-level skills in an emerging economy. Pretoria: ASSAf; 2010. Available from: http://www.assaf.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/40696-Boldesign-PHD-small.pdf
2. Utilising knowledge for development: Ten priorities for Africa [homepage on the Internet]. No date [cited 2010 Oct 15] Available from: www.worldbank.org
3. King DA. The scientific impact of nations: What different countries get for their research spending. Nature. 2004;430:311−316.
4. South African PhD project. [homepage on the Internet]. No date [cited 2010 Oct 15] Available from: http://www.phdproject.co.za
5. Reihling HCW. Bioprospecting the African Renaissance: The new value of muthi in South Africa. J Ethnobiol Ethnomedicine 2008;4:9.
6. Square kilometer array Africa. [homepage on the Internet]. No date [cited 2010 Oct 15] Available from: http://www.ska.ac.za/
7. Mazrui AA. Towards re-Africanizing African universities: Who killed intellectualism in the post-colonial era? Alternatives. 2003;2:135−163.
Vol. 106 No. 11/12 Page 2 of 2